How Long is Long Enough After 9/11? Cloverfield Answers.
How long is long enough following the tragedy of 9/11 to begin to pry into the American psyche, probe our collective memories of that horrifying day, and begin to exploit those strong and painful emotions? How long is long enough to treat 9/11 as nothing more than a pop cultural reference used to evoke feelings of horror and dread?
According to J.J. Abrams and Entertainment Weekly, the answer is just under six years.
As I browsed the latest EW, I turned the page and was hit by the image on the left below--a teaser poster for the new, top secret movie coming from the producer of "Lost" and "Alias." I found it's visual reference to 9/11 quite shocking. Lady Liberty stands against a smoldering Manhattan, plumes of smoke rising from towers and drifting to the right.
Even the use of the date on the poster--the film will be released on 1/18/08--seemed to touch a nerve. After all, no other great tragedies are referenced simply by date. We don't speak of 12/7 but of "Pearl Harbor", and the "Oklahoma City bombing" is not known as 4/19. So, the omission of a movie title and focus on the date only serves to reinforce the reference to the 9/11 terrorist attack.
I wondered if EW would take J.J. to task for exploiting the tragedy, a charge leveled by many against the very noble and worthy film "United 93" little over a year ago. To my surprise, there is no mention in the accompanying article about the way the poster plays on our recollection of that day six years ago when the world stopped, looked in horror, and cried.
Are we beginning to forget? Have we grown so tired of Bush and Company's unfailing use of the term "9/11" to justify rights abuses and war that it has lost its meaning? Or have we now, after six years, arrived at some psychic "statute of limitations" on 9/11's anger, grief, and dread?
I don't actually object to the poster and am intrigued by the effective, teasing marketing campaign. But I do find it fascinating how quickly we've gone from cries of "too soon" over United 93 's vivid tribute to the heroes on that flight to indifference over a monster movie's plagiarizing of 9/11 imagery.










